« L'Homme des Montagnes--Man of the Mountains | Main | Press Release - Guest Blogger Week on KMM »

Mar27
The New Hotness (Or the Encyclopedia Britannica’s Guide To Becoming Internet RoadKill)

Editor's Note: We want to thank Chartreuse for contributing this post as a Guest Blogger on Know More Media. You can read Chartreuse regularly on chartreuse.wordpress.com.

In case you haven’t been paying attention, one of the more interesting fights in cyberspace is the one going on between Encyclopedia Britannica and Wikipedia.

In December of last year Nature magazine conducted a head-to-head competition between Wikipedia and Britannica, having experts compare 42 science-related articles. The result was that Wikipedia had about 4 errors per article, while Britannica had about 3.

Last week Britannica released -- not corrections -- but a corporate response stating that 'Nature's research was invalid [...] almost everything about the Nature's investigation was wrong and misleading.'

Here’s the problem. It took Britannica 3 months to respond.

The damage has already been done.

Now EB is, at its core, everything the internet is not.

It’s elitist.

It’s expensive.

And as we just learned, it’s slow.

If you are in the information business. And everyone is. You need to be everything that EB is not.

You need to be open.

You need to be cheap.

And you need to be fast.

Let's look at trade magazines.


Now I have read a lot of trade magazines in my life. Looking for ideas I could steal so I could use them in the music business. Really.

Now trade magazines, by there very nature, are just like Britannica.

They are elitist.

They are expensive.

And they are slow.

If I was starting a trade magazine today, it would be available on the internet, it would be free, and it would be updated constantly.

But everybody already knows that.

But here’s what you may not know.

If you are only thinking about the internet you are already behind.

You need to be thinking about how you can bring open, cheap and fast information to every platform.

You need to be thinking about social networks, mobile devices and podcasts.

Why?

Again, let’s look at Wikipedia and Britannica. Despite literally owning the encyclopedia market Britannica is struggling.

One of the reasons Wikipedia is so popular is that anyone with an internet connection can be involved.

You can edit articles.

You can comment.

Or you can just hang out and chat with other Wikipedia members.

It’s almost like a club.

It’s a…social network with the audience having a vested interest in its success.

Now Britannica is just the opposite.

You got a question? Too bad.

You got a comment? Who cares?

They want your money and that’s it.

It’s nothing like a club. It’s a…anti-social club. The audience could care less if it lives or dies.

For those still paying attention Wikipedia is the new hotness and Encyclopedia Britannica old and busted.

Again.

Wikipedia=new hotness.

Encyclopedia Britannica=old and busted.

Now just like your business, Encyclopedia Britannica can be saved. They can start implementing ideas to create community. They can become proactive instead of reactive. They can leverage their dwindling prestige into long-term value. They can start thinking about how to make information available on the platforms people will care about in the future.

But it may take longer than 3 months.


11 Comments


Good points in a unique style. Nice post.

» Odds and Ends from ThePublishingSpot
I just opened up the KnowMoreMedia blog, the newswire for my parental blog company, only to find this post by one of ThePublishingSpot's  pals, Chartreuse.  He is writing about encyclopedias, of all things. Keep reading his stuff, if only for... [Read More]

I remember growing up reading from a huge set of World Book encyclopedias. I loved them then, but I feel no need to return to them now that I have instant, free access to the World Wide Encyclopedia. Thanks, chartreuse, for the entertaining and insightful post.
That was a very opinionated and insightful post. Britannica is no doubt one of the most powerful source of information on the internet but not the friendliest one. Their slow and negative response will bring them more of the negative vibes. They need to get their acts straight and embrace the new community mantra. Even the Nike in collabration with Google (Joga.com) is reacting to the new and flourishing culture of nurturing communities out of your audience.

» Wikipedia = new hotness. Encyclopedia Britannica = old and busted. from Panasonic Youth
Chartreuse nails another one - the full article at Know More Media. Plus, that quote makes a great headline. ... [Read More]

I'm trying to work out if this post has a too-subtle sarcasm that I'm missing, or whether I've just fallen through the looking-glass into bizarro-world.

» Press Release - Guest Blogger Week on KMM from Know More Media
We distributed a press release today through our exclusive PR sponsor, PRWeb, about our Guest Blogger Week. Read the release here or go to PRWeb's direct link to view it.----------------------Orange County, CA (PRWEB) March 28, 2006 -- Know More Media,... [Read More]

» Guest Bloggers on the KMM Network, Mon & Tue from Know More Media
The guest blogger contributions to our network during our Guest Blogger Week are heating up. We’d like to recognize them here.  On Monday, the following guest bloggers were published: Chartreuse: ‘The New Hotness (or the Encyclopedia B... [Read More]

» Stewart Mader: You Either Get It (Wikipedia) Or You Don't (Britannica) from BusinessBlogWire
Note by Easton: Thanks go to Stewart Mader for this guest post, which forms part of the Know More Media Guest Blogger Week event.  Stewart has also posted about wikis twice this week at this blog (see "Wiki vs. Blog"... [Read More]

testcomment
testcomment

submit a trackback

TrackBack URL for this entry:

post a comment

Name, Email Address, and URL are not required fields.





Comment Preview

« L'Homme des Montagnes--Man of the Mountains | Main | Press Release - Guest Blogger Week on KMM »

Know More Media is an online publisher of business information and news. Our authors provide a broad spectrum of business knowledge, publishing their expertise on a continual basis.

Search Network:
Subscribe
What's this?

know more media network

View Network Map

Network Feed List (OPML)

Know More Media Network
Feed


we support unitus

PRWeb



Know More Media is a network of business related blogs.

Here are some current headlines from some of our business publications:

ProductivityGoal

CallCenterScript

AdHurl

TheBizofKnowledge

LandingTheDeal

CustomersAreAlways

HealthCareVox

BrainBasedBusiness

TheInsurancePolicy

MarketingBlurb